Jump to content

High level 0: Difference between revisions

From OESI Wiki
Created page with "{| class="wikitable" |+ !CMM Segment (Line Title) !Risk Source !Risk Name !Impact !Typical Responses |- |Initial |Technology access gap |Digital divide |Reduced participation, higher dropout, inequity |Device loans, low-bandwidth content, asynchronous options, ISP partnerships, triage support |- |Initial |Process immaturity |Inconsistent course delivery |Confused learners, missed objectives, reputation damage |Minimum delivery standards, instructor quick-guides, peer..."
 
No edit summary
 
(9 intermediate revisions by the same user not shown)
Line 1: Line 1:
{| class="wikitable"
{| class="wikitable"
|+
|+
!CMM Segment
!CMM Segment <br /> (Line Title)
(Line Title)
!Risk Source
!Risk Source
!Risk Name
!Risk Name
!Impact
!Impact
!Typical
!Typical Responses
Responses
|-
|-
|Initial
|Initial
|Technology access gap
|Technology access gap
|Digital divide
|[[Digital divide (High Level 0)|Digital divide]]
|Reduced participation,
|Reduced participation, higher dropout, inequity
higher dropout, inequity
|Device loans, low-bandwidth content, asynchronous options, ISP partnerships, triage support
|Device loans,
low-bandwidth content,  
asynchronous options,  
ISP partnerships,
triage support
|-
|-
|Initial
|Initial
|Process immaturity
|Process immaturity
|Inconsistent course delivery
|[[Inconsistent course delivery (High Level 0)|Inconsistent course delivery]]
|Confused learners,  
|Confused learners, missed objectives, reputation damage
missed objectives,
|Minimum delivery standards, instructor quick-guides, peer mentoring, centralized templates
reputation damage
|Minimum delivery standards,
instructor quick-guides,  
peer mentoring,
centralized templates
|-
|-
|Initial
|Initial
|Assessment design weakness
|Assessment design weakness
|High cheating /
|[[High cheating / academic integrity Inc. (High Level 0)|High cheating / academic integrity Inc.]]
academic integrity Inc.
|Erosion of standards, unfair grading, regulatory issues
|Erosion of standards,
|Authentic assessments, randomized banks, honor pledges, remote proctoring, forensic review
unfair grading,
regulatory issues
|Authentic assessments,  
randomized banks,
honor pledges,  
remote proctoring,  
forensic review
|-
|-
|Managed
|Managed
|Scheduling &amp;amp; workload
|Scheduling &amp; workload
|Time-management failure
|[[Time-management failure (High Level 0)|Time-management failure]]
|Lower completion,  
|Lower completion, stress, poorer outcomes
stress, poorer outcomes
|Pacing guides, check-ins, automated reminders, smaller milestones, study skills modules
|Pacing guides,  
check-ins,
automated reminders,
smaller milestones,
study skills modules
|-
|-
|Managed
|Managed
|Tech reliability &amp;amp; support
|Tech reliability &amp; support
|Platform downtime &amp;amp;  
|[[Platform downtime &amp; poor support (High Level 0)|Platform downtime &amp; poor support]]
poor support
|Missed classes/assessments, frustration
|Missed classes/assessments,
|SLA with provider, redundant channels, extended support, status page, contingency procedures
 
frustration
|SLA with provider,  
redundant channels,
extended support,
status page,
contingency procedures
|-
|-
|Managed
|Managed
|Data &amp;amp; privacy weak
|Data &amp; privacy weak
|Student data exposure
|[[Student data exposure (High Level 0)|Student data exposure]]
|Legal/regulatory fines,  
|Legal/regulatory fines, trust loss
trust loss
|Privacy settings enforcement, staff training, data minimization, backups, encrypted storage
|Privacy settings enforcement,
staff training,
data minimization,
backups, encrypted storage
|-
|-
|Defined
|Defined
|Pedagogy gap
|Pedagogy gap
|Poor instructional  
|[[Poor instructional design (online) (High Level 0)|Poor instructional design (online)]]
design (online)
|Low engagement, passive learning, poor transfer
|Low engagement,  
|ID review mandatory, online pedagogy training, standardized outcomes mapped to activities, peer review
passive learning,
poor transfer
|ID review mandatory,  
online pedagogy training,
standardized outcomes
mapped to activities,
peer review
|-
|-
|Defined
|Defined
|Social/engagement factors
|Social/engagement factors
|Student isolation &amp;amp;  
|[[Student isolation &amp; weak soft skills (High Level 0)|Student isolation &amp; weak soft skills]]
weak soft skills
|Lower participation, mental health issues, weaker collaboration
|Lower participation,  
|Synchronous group tasks, virtual community spaces, peer mentoring, wellbeing resources
mental health issues,  
weaker collaboration
|Synchronous group tasks,  
virtual community spaces,
peer mentoring,
wellbeing resources
|-
|-
|Defined
|Defined
|Accessibility oversight
|Accessibility oversight
|Non-compliance with
|[[Non-compliance with accessibility (High Level 0)|Non-compliance with accessibility]]
accessibility
|Exclusion of learners with disabilities, legal risk
|Exclusion of learners with  
|Accessibility checklist in sign-off, captioning, screen-reader testing, remediation plan
disabilities, legal risk
|Accessibility checklist in sign-off,
captioning,
screen-reader testing,  
remediation plan
|-
|-
|Quantitatively
|Quantitatively Managed
Managed
|Analytics blind spots
|Analytics blind spots
|Incomplete/misinterpreted
|[[Incomplete/misinterpreted analytics (High Level 0)|Incomplete/misinterpreted analytics]]
analytics
|Wrong interventions, wasted resources
|Wrong interventions,
|Consistent metrics (engagement, timeliness), instructor dashboards, model validation, data governance
wasted resources
|Consistent metrics (engagement, timeliness),  
instructor dashboards, model validation,
data governance
|-
|-
|Quantitatively
|Quantitatively Managed
Managed
|Quality variability
|Quality variability
|Inconsistent outcomes
|[[Inconsistent outcomes across sections (High Level 0)|Inconsistent outcomes across sections]]
across sections
|Accreditation risk, student dissatisfaction
|Accreditation risk,
|Statistical monitoring, standard rubrics, targeted faculty coaching
student dissatisfaction
|Statistical monitoring,  
standard rubrics,
targeted faculty coaching
|-
|-
|Quantitatively
|Quantitatively Managed
Managed
|Security threats
|Security threats
|Cyberattacks
|[[Cyberattacks (phishing, account takeover) (High Level 0)|Cyberattacks (phishing, account takeover)]]
(phishing, account takeover)
|Service disruption, data breach, exam compromise
|Service disruption,
|MFA, phishing training, incident response playbooks, pen-testing, patch cadence
data breach,
exam compromise
|MFA,  
phishing training,
incident response playbooks,
pen-testing,
patch cadence
|-
|-
|Optimizing
|Optimizing
|Innovation risk
|Innovation risk
|Poorly tested new tools  
|[[Poorly tested new tools (AI, XR) (High Level 0)|Poorly tested new tools (AI, XR)]]
(AI, XR)
|Wasted investment, learner confusion, bias issues
|Wasted investment,
|Pilot programs, ethical review, phased rollouts with metrics, vendor due diligence
learner confusion,
bias issues
|Pilot programs,
ethical review,
phased rollouts with metrics,
vendor due diligence
|-
|-
|Optimizing
|Optimizing
|Change fatigue
|Change fatigue
|Overload from  
|[[Overload from continuous updates (High Level 0)|Overload from continuous updates]]
continuous updates
|Reduced adoption, staff burnout
|Reduced adoption,  
|Stakeholder co-design, prioritized roadmap, communication calendar, change impact assessments
staff burnout
|Stakeholder co-design,
prioritized roadmap,
communication calendar,
change impact assessments
|-
|-
|Optimizing
|Optimizing
|Long-term wellbeing
|Long-term wellbeing
|Chronic screen-time
|[[Chronic screen-time &amp; mental decline (High Level 0)|Chronic screen-time &amp; mental decline]]
&amp;amp; mental decline
|Reduced retention, health complaints, poorer learning
|Reduced retention,  
|Blended modality targets, enforced breaks, wellbeing curriculum, survey monitoring and support referrals
health complaints,
poorer learning
|Blended modality targets,
enforced breaks,  
wellbeing curriculum,
survey monitoring and support referrals
|}
|}
[[Risk model|<big>Back to Risk Model</big>]]
</br>
<span style="font-size:150%;">[[Risk Model|Back to Risk Model start page]]

Latest revision as of 15:41, 24 August 2026

CMM Segment
(Line Title)
Risk Source Risk Name Impact Typical Responses
Initial Technology access gap Digital divide Reduced participation, higher dropout, inequity Device loans, low-bandwidth content, asynchronous options, ISP partnerships, triage support
Initial Process immaturity Inconsistent course delivery Confused learners, missed objectives, reputation damage Minimum delivery standards, instructor quick-guides, peer mentoring, centralized templates
Initial Assessment design weakness High cheating / academic integrity Inc. Erosion of standards, unfair grading, regulatory issues Authentic assessments, randomized banks, honor pledges, remote proctoring, forensic review
Managed Scheduling & workload Time-management failure Lower completion, stress, poorer outcomes Pacing guides, check-ins, automated reminders, smaller milestones, study skills modules
Managed Tech reliability & support Platform downtime & poor support Missed classes/assessments, frustration SLA with provider, redundant channels, extended support, status page, contingency procedures
Managed Data & privacy weak Student data exposure Legal/regulatory fines, trust loss Privacy settings enforcement, staff training, data minimization, backups, encrypted storage
Defined Pedagogy gap Poor instructional design (online) Low engagement, passive learning, poor transfer ID review mandatory, online pedagogy training, standardized outcomes mapped to activities, peer review
Defined Social/engagement factors Student isolation & weak soft skills Lower participation, mental health issues, weaker collaboration Synchronous group tasks, virtual community spaces, peer mentoring, wellbeing resources
Defined Accessibility oversight Non-compliance with accessibility Exclusion of learners with disabilities, legal risk Accessibility checklist in sign-off, captioning, screen-reader testing, remediation plan
Quantitatively Managed Analytics blind spots Incomplete/misinterpreted analytics Wrong interventions, wasted resources Consistent metrics (engagement, timeliness), instructor dashboards, model validation, data governance
Quantitatively Managed Quality variability Inconsistent outcomes across sections Accreditation risk, student dissatisfaction Statistical monitoring, standard rubrics, targeted faculty coaching
Quantitatively Managed Security threats Cyberattacks (phishing, account takeover) Service disruption, data breach, exam compromise MFA, phishing training, incident response playbooks, pen-testing, patch cadence
Optimizing Innovation risk Poorly tested new tools (AI, XR) Wasted investment, learner confusion, bias issues Pilot programs, ethical review, phased rollouts with metrics, vendor due diligence
Optimizing Change fatigue Overload from continuous updates Reduced adoption, staff burnout Stakeholder co-design, prioritized roadmap, communication calendar, change impact assessments
Optimizing Long-term wellbeing Chronic screen-time & mental decline Reduced retention, health complaints, poorer learning Blended modality targets, enforced breaks, wellbeing curriculum, survey monitoring and support referrals


Back to Risk Model start page